The Conflict Question

Call it the third rail of the wealth business: conflict of interest.

It’s the mantra independent registered investment advisors constantly evoke when attempting to distinguish themselves from their brokerage firm brethren: we are fee-based, don’t sell proprietary products and are therefore pure as the virgin snow. We have no conflict of interests. None. Zero.

But could this endlessly repeated claim turn out be an Achilles Heel for the swelling number of RIAs who are so sure their business model is the Next Big Thing?

This elephant in the room was broached at last week’s MarketCounsel Summit inLas Vegaswhen Knut Rostad of the Institute for the Fiduciary Standard publicly asked Elliot Weissbluth, chief executive of High Tower Advisors, if he really had “zero” conflicts of interest.

Weissbluth replied that if a business is making money from a client in two different business lines, there’s a conflict. HighTower, he continued, has “structured out the business conflicts” and does not get paid twice.

But that hardly ends the debate. There is, in fact, a growing chorus of critics who are pointing out potential conflicts, or, at the least, deficiencies in the standard RIA business model of getting paid by a fee based on a percentage of assets under management.

During the summer, Charles Ellis, author of  the investing classic “Winning the Loser’s Game: Timeless Strategies for Successful Investing”  argued in the Financial Analysts Journal  that investment management fees “should really be based on what investors are getting in the returns that managers produce.”

Clients  who take a car in for repairs are unlikely to allow a mechanic to charge them merely for just keeping the car in his garage, Ellis argues, so why would a client who can mach the market’s performance  by buying  an index fund for merely five basis points pay an advisor much more to simply do the same thing?

According to Bert Whitehead, founder of the Alliance of Cambridge Advisors, conflicts are “inherent” in assets under management pricing.

AUM compensation poses conflicts, Whitehead contended in an Investment News op-ed, when wealth managers weigh in on decisions that could directly affect their own revenues, such as advising clients on whether or not to invest in real estate or buy an annuity; make a sizable charitable contribution or roll over a 401(k) from an employer’s fund manger (especially if costs are equivalent or lower) to their own firm.

While conflicts in the old commission model were “right there in your face to see,” says industry guru Chip Roame, managing partner of Tiburon Strategic Advisors, “nearly any model you develop has conflicts of interest, [including] fee models. The most obvious is when a client wants to withdraw funds from you and pay off his mortgage: do you say yes or no?”

Then there’s the extremely sensitive matter of what wealth managers might be getting from third-party fund managers and what is being disclosed, a conflict of interest if there ever was one.

Are financial advisors getting in-kind compensation such as research support or other benefits?  Are they using an outsourced product platform that may have other conflict issues? Are they getting some sort of payment or “retrocession deals” that are hidden or embedded costs within a product’s fees? Or are they getting old-fashioned under-the-table kickbacks, more politely know as “finder’s fees?”

The lack of transparency regarding public disclosure of fee data and portfolio performance was highlighted in an analysis of the websites of 40 of the world’s largest wealth managers done last year by the Swiss-based research firm MyPrivateBanking.

Only 18 per cent of the wealth managers offered precise, quantitative data on fees, the study found, and just eight per cent published at least a three-year track record of the performance of their discretionary accounts.

As for the advice part of the “value proposition,” Andrew Haigney, managing director at EL CAP Investment Consultants, has argued in Registered Rep that while clients are paying for investment advice every day, “the advice rarely changes. It’s akin to hiring an attorney to write a simple will and keeping the attorney on permanent retainer, paying him a yearly percentage of the value of your estate.”

Of course, RIAs can always charge clients flat retainer fees, or by the hour or even, as Ellis suggests, based on performance. But few do, and from a business point of view, have good reasons not to. Independent advisors will also have plenty of valid counter arguments against charges of conflicts of interest.

But that doesn’t mean that none exist. And it won’t stop a new breed of competitors from exploiting any vulnerability RIAs may have.

In fact, at the most recent Tiburon CEO Summit inNew Yorkthis spring, Roame warned industry leaders not to be too complacent. A whole new crop of Internet-based firms such as Betterment, Goalgami, Personal Capital and Wealth Front are on the horizon, he said,  with impressive offerings that have great appeal to a generation that have grown up on the Web.

These new competitors are leading with ETF and DFA offerings, and offering state of the art simplicity and transparency when it comes to investment management.

With no conflicts of interests, unlike their competitors, they will undoubtedly claim.

 

 

225 thoughts on “The Conflict Question

  1. Pingback: ブライトリング

  2. Pingback: maillot liverpool 2013 exterieur

  3. Pingback: maillot manchester city third

  4. Pingback: mbt shoes

  5. Pingback: deutschland trikot 2014

  6. Pingback: lunette de soleil aviateur

  7. Pingback: parajumpers homme

  8. Pingback: terrance

  9. Pingback: cheap sunglasses

  10. Pingback: air max yeezy

  11. Pingback: air max classic bw

  12. Pingback: Christian Louboutin Paris

  13. Pingback: chanel handbags

  14. Pingback: chaussures louboutin

  15. Pingback: cheap louboutin outlet

  16. Pingback: エルメス 新作 バッグ 2013

  17. Pingback: ray ban outlet

  18. Pingback: pink timberland boots

  19. Pingback: dofollow backlinks from wikis

  20. Pingback: celine ラゲージ 流行り

  21. Pingback: セリーヌ カバ プライマリーレッド

  22. Pingback: セリーヌ ラゲージ 雨

  23. Pingback: セリーヌ 長財布 バイカラー 定価

  24. Pingback: Ian Filippini Santa Barbara

  25. Pingback: エルメス 財布 水色

  26. Pingback: エルメス お買い物 ブログ

  27. Pingback: エルメス バーキン コピー

  28. Pingback: エルメス バッグ カタログ

  29. Pingback: エルメス ボリード 人気

  30. Pingback: セリーヌ 財布 バイカラー 激安

  31. Pingback: セリーヌ バッグ 新作 秋冬

  32. Pingback: エルメス 時計 通販

  33. Pingback: セリーヌ 財布 年齢

  34. Pingback: セリーヌ ハンカチ 通販

  35. Pingback: read this for quick fat burning using healthy diet supplements

  36. Pingback: セリーヌ バッグ ポシェット

  37. Pingback: セリーヌ トリオ ヤフオク

  38. Pingback: click here

  39. Pingback: who sells cotton yoga strap online straps

  40. Pingback: professional San Antonio web design

  41. Pingback: san Antonio iphone app development

  42. Pingback: エルメス 長財布 激安

  43. Pingback: エルメス ブレスレット ホワイトゴールド

  44. Pingback: louboutin outlet

  45. Pingback: San Antonio website design

  46. Pingback: humaita sediou a 1a fase da copa dos rios de futebol

  47. Pingback: Celine Handbags Outlet Store

  48. Pingback: hollister arc baie t-shirts jaune

  49. Pingback: christian louboutin shoes

  50. Pingback: coach outlet online

  51. Pingback: yuna big bang promosi kakao talk

  52. Pingback: トリーバーチ ダウン

  53. Pingback: トリーバーチ 長財布 ゴールド

  54. Pingback: トリーバーチ 長財布 アマンダ

  55. Pingback: tory burch メガネ

  56. Pingback: トリーバーチ ジョッキーブーツ

  57. Pingback: Cheap Gucci

  58. Pingback: 16987.html

  59. Pingback: lv replica handbags

  60. Pingback: mbt shoes

  61. Pingback: elite cosmetic surgeon red bluff

  62. Pingback: hermes sac prix

  63. Pingback: shoes with red bottoms

  64. Pingback: oakley prescription glasses

  65. Pingback: hermes borse prezzi

  66. Pingback: oakley jawbone

  67. Pingback: coachoutletstoreonlinemax.com

  68. Pingback: mulberry sale

  69. Pingback: oakley inmate

  70. Pingback: oakley fast jacket

  71. Pingback: ray bans sunglasses

  72. Pingback: borse usate alviero martini

  73. Pingback: louis vuitton usa

  74. Pingback: oakley antix

  75. Pingback: louis vuitton travel bag

  76. Pingback: トリーバーチ リング

  77. Pingback: トリーバーチ アウトレット 公式

  78. Pingback: louis vuitton luggage

  79. Pingback: トリーバーチ ポーチ 付録

  80. Pingback: トリーバーチ アウトレット 沖縄

  81. Pingback: Occhiali Da Sole Ray Ban Wayfarer Rb2140 Grigio Lente Rossa Tela

  82. Pingback: borsello uomo prada

  83. Pingback: tory burch flip flops sale

  84. Pingback: cheap ray ban sunglasses

  85. Pingback: coach outlet online

  86. Pingback: ray ban da vista

  87. Pingback: cheap oakley sunglasses

  88. Pingback: cheap nike air max 90

  89. Pingback: tory burch sandals sale

  90. Pingback: oakleys sunglasses

  91. Pingback: oakley flak jacket

  92. Pingback: 2014 Prada Glace Calf Leather Flap Bag BN2661 in Black

  93. Pingback: ポールスミス トートバッグ

  94. Pingback: gucci firenze on line

  95. Pingback: coach factory store online

  96. Pingback: toms

  97. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet online

  98. Pingback: prada カナパ lサイズ

  99. Pingback: prada バッグ 通販

  100. Pingback: prada ポーチ 安

  101. Pingback: prada リボン キーケース コピー

  102. Pingback: oakley prescription glasses

  103. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet store

  104. Pingback: michael kors monogram handbags

  105. Pingback: discount christian louboutin

  106. Pingback: Cheap Louis Vuitton outlet

  107. Pingback: 奢侈品包包

  108. Pingback: christian louboutin boots

  109. Pingback: scarpe hogan offerte

  110. Pingback: cheap oakley sunglasses

  111. Pingback: michael kors outlet online

  112. Pingback: wow gold

  113. Pingback: replica givenchy handbags uk

  114. Pingback: tory burch slippers

  115. Pingback: Louboutin Escarpin

  116. Pingback: oakley crosshair

  117. Pingback: coachbags

  118. Pingback: karen millen uk

  119. Pingback: louis vuitton handbags on sale

  120. Pingback: coach factory outlet

  121. Pingback: coachoutlet.coachfactoryoutletcool.com

  122. Pingback: zaino timberland

  123. Pingback: mulberry outlet

  124. Pingback: louboutin femme pas cher

  125. Pingback: Air Jordan Nike 12 XII Retro Baskets Noir/Rouge

  126. Pingback: camiseta de futbol outlet

  127. Pingback: Günstig Hollister

  128. Pingback: batwolf oakley

  129. Pingback: tory burch wallet

  130. Pingback: onde comprar camisetas baratas em sp

  131. Pingback: cheap oakley sunglasses

  132. Pingback: trio alviero martini prezzo

  133. Pingback: wowgold

  134. Pingback: louis vuitton wallet

  135. Pingback: borse alviero martini

  136. Pingback: louis vuitton bags on sale

  137. Pingback: nike air max command

  138. Pingback: louis vuitton handbags official site

  139. Pingback: Concord 11

  140. Pingback: scarpe hogan 543

  141. Pingback: china

  142. Pingback: ray bans wayfarer

  143. Pingback: louboutin homme

  144. Pingback: oakley glasses

  145. Pingback: Adidas F50 Soccer Shoes

  146. Pingback: sac a main dior pas cher

  147. Pingback: Where To Buy Sport Blue 6s

  148. Pingback: Jordan 6 Retro Sport Blue

  149. Pingback: coach factory outlet

  150. Pingback: cheap ray ban

  151. Pingback: air max donna

  152. Pingback: Pre Order Sport Blue 6s

  153. Pingback: chanel bags

  154. Pingback: nike air max

  155. Pingback: ray ban rb2140

  156. Pingback: gucci outlet online

  157. Pingback: Sport Blue 6s

  158. Pingback: coach outlet online

  159. Pingback: hollister womens hoodies

  160. Pingback: Authentic Carmine 6s

  161. Pingback: nike air max skyline

  162. Pingback: Real Sport Blue 6s

  163. Pingback: air max skyline

  164. Pingback: Chanel Handbags for sale

  165. Pingback: nike air max donna

  166. Pingback: camiseta del real madrid 2014 barata

  167. Pingback: Air Jordan 6 Sport Blue

  168. Pingback: camiseta real madrid

  169. Pingback: Sport Blue 6

  170. Pingback: donde comprar camisetas de futbol originales chile

  171. Pingback: buy YUMS snapback hats

  172. Pingback: Longchamp Le Pliage authentique Arbre de Vie Marine Sacs

  173. Pingback: Geelong Cats Snapback Caps

  174. Pingback: Mcm Bags

  175. Pingback: Buy Sport Blue 6s

  176. Pingback: renginiai.info/?p=573

  177. Pingback: revistaflacara.ro/?p=254

  178. Pingback: How To Get Concord 11s

  179. Pingback: cobblawgroup.net/?p=3863

  180. Pingback: negozi timberland napoli

  181. Pingback: Sale Soccer Cleats

  182. Pingback: hollister online shop

  183. Pingback: air jordan

  184. Pingback: Authentic Messi F50 Soccer Shoes

  185. Pingback: How To Get Sport Blue 6s

  186. Pingback: ray ban wayfarer da vista

  187. Pingback: Buy Carmine 6s

  188. Pingback: Cheap Sport Blue 6s

  189. Pingback: replica Dior soft on sale

  190. Pingback: Pre Order Carmine 6s

  191. Pingback: camisetas de futbol de china

  192. Pingback: camisetas de futbol zenit

  193. Pingback: bluearena.gr/?id=254

  194. Pingback: Sport Blue 6s Online

  195. Pingback: Sport Blue 3

  196. Pingback: http://hiendcorner.pl/?p=12302

  197. Pingback: クリスチャンルブタン アウトレット

  198. Pingback: History Of Jordan 6

  199. Pingback: cnmedia.fr/?p=2206

  200. Pingback: 894

  201. Pingback: alviero martini outlet

  202. Pingback: maillot Negredo pas cher

  203. Pingback: chanel iphoneケース 激安

  204. Pingback: 最新 販売 chanel 財布 スーパーコピー

  205. Pingback: portefeuille lancel

  206. Pingback: celine pitelet

  207. Pingback: Ray Ban Polarized lunette Outlet RB2049

  208. Pingback: hermes bags for less

  209. Pingback: scarpe hogan offerte

  210. Pingback: liste magasin hollister

  211. Pingback: jordan shoes wolf grey 5

  212. Pingback: Air Max Hyperfuse

  213. Pingback: Air Max 1 Femme

  214. Pingback: Nike Air Max Classic

  215. Pingback: louboutin femme

  216. Pingback: strettonclimatecare.org.uk/?id=278

  217. Pingback: Bottes Louboutin Pas Cher

  218. Pingback: ray ban australia

  219. Pingback: Louboutin Un Bout Pas Cher

  220. Pingback: miumiu 財布 代引き

  221. Pingback: Bottes Louboutin

  222. Pingback: cheap shoes

  223. Pingback: michael kors outlet online

  224. Pingback: nike free 2

  225. Pingback: Longchamp Sac Pas Cher

Comments are closed.